離開
進入《TAIPEI TIMES》 Heart attack survivor to sue ministry over app
An Apple Watch Friday displays a message that to configure the electrocardiogram, the iPhone Health app must be opened. Photo: Hung Jui-chin, Taipei Times
DIGITAL MONITOR: A Tainan man said he was wrongly diagnosed with acid reflux and his condition could have been detected if an ECG app was available in Taiwan
By Hung Jui-ching and Jonathan Chin / Staff reporter, with staff writer
A Tainan man who survived a heart attack said on Friday that he would sue the Ministry of Health and Welfare for not making a mobile electrocardiography （ECG） app available for Apple Watch Series 4.
The tech worker, surnamed Lee （李）, said he would file a civil lawsuit for damages and an administrative suit for negligence if the ministry does not change its regulations, which he said resulted in the app being disabled in Taiwan.
Lee said that he bought the smartwatch from a friend in the US in March, a month before the ministry banned the app on the grounds that it would turn the smartwatch into an unapproved medical device.
The smartwatch cost him about NT$140,000 and he had bought it specifically for the heart monitoring app, as he was feeling unwell and was worried about his well-being, because his family has a history of heart disease, he said.
When he sought medical help at the time, doctors misdiagnosed him with acid reflux, Lee said, adding that his heart condition could have been discovered had the app been available in Taiwan.
The misdiagnosis wasted time that could have been used to prevent the heart attack, he said.
“The ministry’s decision in April, which was ill-advised, removed an app that is crucially important to people with heart conditions,” Lee said.
Instead of standing in the way of progress, the government should embrace technology and allow the use of electronic devices for medical purposes, as long as they are used to supplement doctors and not to replace them, he said.
People with heart conditions have long urged the government to allow ECG apps on smartwatches, but to no avail, which is why he is using the lawsuits to pressure the government, Lee said.
Food and Drug Administration official Lin Hsin-hui （林欣慧） said that Apple decides whether to make heart monitoring apps available in regional markets.
“When the US Food and Drug Administration approved Apple to release its ECG app, we sent an inquiry to the Taiwan branch of Apple and it said: ‘Due to considerations of global business strategy, there are no plans to release the ECG app in Taiwan at this time,’” Lin said.
The are many approved heart monitoring devices for household use and they are widely available on the commercial market, she added.
Tainan Municipal An-Nan Hospital deputy superintendent Lin Sheng-che （林聖哲） said that smartwatches are no substitute for doctors, because it takes medical professionals to review and interpret ECG readings.
However, wearable devices with ECG apps could be a valuable early detection tool for the average person, who is not necessarily alert to chest tightness, arrhythmia or other symptoms of heart conditions, he said.
“The government should consider allowing such apps to be released,” he said.
Taipei Medical University Hospital cardiologist Huang Chun-yao （黃群耀） said that the heart rate is one of the many physiological data monitored by medical ECG devices, adding that the capabilities of wearable heart monitoring devices is “uncertain.”
Democratic Progressive Party Legislator Chen Ting-fei （陳亭妃） said she would ask the ministry to weigh the opinions of experts and the public on the matter, but added that it is appropriate for regulators to be attentive to risks when evaluating medical devices.
新聞來源：TAIPEI TIMES
